Charitable planning · comparison
Charitable Remainder Trust vs. Donor-Advised Fund
Updated 2026-10-21 · Gregory Garone, CEPA®
Short answer: Use a charitable remainder trust when you want income from the gift and are working with a large appreciated asset. Use a donor-advised fund when you intend the whole gift to go to charity and want low cost, simplicity and an immediate deduction.
Charitable remainder trust vs. Donor-advised fund, side by side
| Question | Charitable remainder trust | Donor-advised fund |
|---|---|---|
| Who receives the money | You (or others) receive payments first; charity gets the remainder | Everything goes to charity through grants you recommend |
| Income to you | Yes, a fixed annuity or a percentage of trust value each year | None |
| Income tax deduction | Only the present value of the charity’s remainder | The full fair market value of the contribution, subject to AGI limits |
| Capital gains on appreciated assets | Not taxed when the trust sells; taxed gradually as payments reach you | Not taxed when the fund sells, and never taxed to you |
| Setup and ongoing cost | Attorney-drafted trust, separate tax return, trustee and valuation costs | Opened online, usually with an administrative fee and no separate return |
| Reversibility | Irrevocable | Contributions are irrevocable, but grant timing is flexible |
When each one tends to fit
Charitable remainder trust may fit when
- You are selling a low-basis business, real estate or stock and want income from it.
- You want to spread a large gain over many years of payments.
- The gift is large enough that legal and administration costs are a small share of it.
Donor-advised fund may fit when
- You give regularly and want to bunch several years of gifts into one tax year.
- You do not need income from the assets you are giving.
- You want the simplest structure with the lowest cost.
An example
Illustration only: someone holding $2 million of stock with a $200,000 basis could contribute it to a 5% charitable remainder unitrust, which would pay about $100,000 in the first year and receive a deduction for the projected remainder. The same stock given to a donor-advised fund would produce a larger deduction and no gain, but no income. The question is whether the income or the larger deduction matters more.
Questions to bring to your CPA or advisor
- Do we need income from this asset, or is it truly surplus?
- Has the sale already been agreed? Assets should be contributed before a binding sale.
- How much of the deduction can we actually use given the AGI limits?
- Who will serve as trustee and prepare the trust’s annual return?
Common questions
Can a charitable remainder trust name a donor-advised fund as the charity?
Often yes, if the trust document allows it. This keeps flexibility over which charities ultimately benefit.
Is there a minimum size for a charitable remainder trust?
There is no legal minimum, but setup and annual costs mean CRTs are usually considered for gifts in the hundreds of thousands of dollars or more.
How much can I deduct for a donor-advised fund gift?
Generally up to 60% of AGI for cash and 30% for appreciated assets held over a year, with a five-year carryforward for the excess.
Do CRT payments keep their tax character?
Yes. Payments are taxed in tiers: ordinary income first, then capital gain, then tax-exempt income, then return of principal.
Sources and limitations
More comparisons
Weighing this choice for real?
Tell us what you are deciding and when. Greg will reply personally.
Submitting a question does not begin an advisory relationship.